The central problem with Quebecor’s unsolicited $31-billion offer to acquire Telus is not the price. It is that, more than four months after the Quebec-based telecom giant first floated the idea privately, it still has not explained how the deal could actually survive Canadian regulatory scrutiny. That gap, more than any financial disagreement, is what makes this proposed merger one of the most consequential and uncertain corporate gambits in recent Canadian telecommunications history.
Quebecor confirmed Monday that it had sent an enhanced version of a private offer originally made in June, seeking to combine its operations with Telus in a deal that would reshape the country’s telecom landscape. Telus acknowledged receiving the proposal on November 9 and said its special committee is conducting a “thorough review.” But Telus board chair John Manley was pointed in his assessment of what is missing: “More than four months after its initial proposal, Québecor has yet to explain how what it is proposing could be approved under the current telecom regulatory framework in Canada.”
That is a damning observation, and it goes to the heart of why this deal, whatever its strategic logic, faces a long and treacherous road.
A Regulatory Landscape Built to Block Exactly This Kind of Deal
Canada’s Competition Bureau confirmed it is “aware of the announcements” and reminded both companies that its mandate is to review mergers for harm to competition, with the authority to take “appropriate action” when a transaction is likely to reduce it. The federal government, through Industry Minister Mélanie Joly, added that the merger would be “rigorously reviewed” by both the Bureau and the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission, framing connectivity as a matter of economic sovereignty and national security, not merely a market question.
The regulatory concern is straightforward. Canada’s telecom market currently rests on four major national providers: Rogers, Bell, Telus and Quebecor. A Telus-Quebecor merger would collapse that to three. Michael Osborne, chair of the Canadian Competition Law Practice at Cozen O’Connor, argues the deal would almost certainly trigger a formal challenge because of what Quebecor already holds. When Videotron acquired Freedom Mobile as a condition of the Rogers-Shaw merger in 2023, it was meant to preserve a fourth competitive force in wireless. Combining Telus’s roughly 30 per cent market share with Freedom’s approximately 12 per cent would, in Osborne’s words, “definitely trip the threshold for a deemed substantial lessening or prevention of competition” under the Competition Act. The very remedy designed to protect competition from the last major telecom consolidation would become the legal obstacle to this one.
Telus itself underscored this contradiction, noting that “existing spectrum policy, the conditions on which recent wireless consolidation was approved, and amendments to the Competition Act give rise to significant concerns regarding the timing, conditions and overall uncertainty associated with obtaining the required regulatory approvals.” Quebecor, for its part, says it has retained competition experts and plans to “collaborate closely” with regulators, but has offered no concrete account of what remedies it would accept to secure approval.
Quebecor’s public rationale is that the combined company would “benefit Canadian consumers through more choice, investment and value.” Economists and legal experts are skeptical. Moshe Lander, an economics professor at Concordia University, acknowledged that mergers can theoretically generate efficiencies, but pointed to the Rogers-Shaw consolidation as a cautionary precedent: that deal did not produce lower prices for consumers of either company. Osborne was blunter still, saying the rationales being offered “don’t really make a lot of sense.” Tahira Dawood of the Public Interest Advocacy Centre warned that reducing the number of competitors affects not just one region but the competitive pressure felt across the entire national market, with consequences for price, quality and service innovation.
What Quebecor has done, by going public with the offer, is shift the pressure onto Telus’s board and onto regulators simultaneously. It framed the disclosure as being “in the public interest,” given the implications for consumers, employees and communities. Telus, meanwhile, said its special committee will also consider “strategic alternatives” to maximize shareholder value, a signal that it is not simply waiting for Quebecor to improve its terms. The two companies are now negotiating in public, with the Competition Bureau, the CRTC and Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada all watching, and with Canadian telecommunications consumers as the ultimate stakeholders in the outcome.
The deeper implication is this: if Quebecor cannot articulate a credible regulatory path, the offer is less a serious merger proposal than a form of strategic pressure, designed to force Telus’s hand or extract concessions. Whether that pressure produces a deal, a counteroffer or simply a prolonged and costly standoff will depend on whether Quebecor can answer the question Telus has been asking since June.
